Type G. Need ya help

[C91BLX7]

Polished my headlights with mothers mag and aluminum, then, plastic polish.

Drivers side headlight came out very good, but passenger, with the aluminum and mag, seems like I hit a soft spot, and haven't had any luck getting it out.

Tried some 1000grit , wasn't taking it off, should I try some more abrasive, or something else or are they screwed?
Before

After


The problem

[TypeG]

i would try buffing it with a drill and powerball type attachment.

was not there before you started? can't say i've seen a headlight do that before. later.

[C91BLX7]

i would try buffing it with a drill and powerball type attachment.

was not there before you started? can't say i've seen a headlight do that before. later.

Nope, almost looks like it melted or something.

I used a angle buffer, high speed, with the fluffy pad, can't remember the name right now.

[TypeG]

probably did melt then. i'd see about sanding it out with 1000g, then 2000 followed by polish. later.

[C91BLX7]

Already tired 1000, think I'm going to start with some 800. Work my way up.